Get paid for the work you did before the insurance company totaled the car.
DSM Negotiator reads the adjuster's emails, drafts your replies with attorney-reviewed citations, and builds an itemized total loss invoice. $1,999 a year, with the full Dent Shop Manager system included.
You did the work. They totaled it. Now you play the reverse card.
Every total loss follows the same script. Here is how it plays out for most shops, and how it plays out for yours with DSM Negotiator.
The cat tent writes it short
After the storm, your customer drives through the insurance company's cat team tent and leaves with a low initial estimate they don't understand. Then they bring the car to you and expect you to fix it for that number.
It totals on the supplement
You tear it down, photograph the real damage and write an honest supplement. Then the car totals, usually because the insurance company put a low value on it. At a fair value, the repair would sit under the total-loss line. Other times the adjuster simply refuses to save the car, even though you want the work.
Then they blame the shop
The adjuster makes the total-loss call and tells you there is nothing you can do, and that they won't pay your storage, teardown or admin fees. Your customer is stuck in the middle with a bill nobody wants to own. That mess is your opening.
You play the reverse card
The insurance company used your shop's time, labor and lot to adjust its loss. DSM Negotiator puts your charges in writing, cites your lien rights where your state's law gives them, and sends an itemized invoice for every day and every hour. When they total it, you take it back.
The laws are complex, and the insurance company would rather you didn't know them.
Learn how shops get paid for storage, teardown and admin on total losses in the free training.
Every hail market is crowded. Total losses are the work nobody is fighting for.
More PDR shops chase the same customers every season, and prices get squeezed. A total loss needs no repair: no tech hours, no parts, no comebacks. Go after those customers on purpose, and bill for the time and space you really put in.
In some markets insurers seem to total almost everything. Every one of those cars is another bill you can send. Their habit becomes your revenue.
Results vary and are not guaranteed. DSM Negotiator is software, not a law firm, and not legal advice.
Meet DSM Negotiator. It does the paperwork fight for you.
One place for each total loss, from the day it's towed in to the day the check clears. Its AI reads the insurance company's emails and writes your replies. We wrote a response for every way we've seen insurers try to get out of paying, and put it behind one button.
Reads the adjuster's move
Paste their email or drop the file in. It files it on the case and tells you what they are doing: stalling, lowballing, asking again for documents they already have, pushing the cost onto your customer, or denying.
Writes your reply
It asks you up to three quick questions, then drafts the letter, firmer each round, backed by attorney-reviewed citations. Nothing goes out until you read it and press send.
Builds the invoice
Your admin, gate and daily storage fees, itemized on a professional Total Loss Invoice. Storage keeps counting every day the car sits on your lot, and every letter picks up the new total. One click for the PDF.
Demo cases with made-up names and numbers. DSM Negotiator is software, not a law firm, and not legal advice.
You did all the work. Then they totaled it.
Then the adjuster tells you:
“We’re not paying admin fees.”
“We only pay storage up to our daily cap.”
“Sorry, there’s nothing we can do.”
What if total losses became the highest-margin work in your shop?
Results from my own shop. Yours depend on your claims, your state and your follow-through.
Real checks from my shop, on cars the insurance company totaled.
Every one of these cars was a total loss. We didn’t fix them, and we still got paid for our work, our lot and our storage. Customer names, claim numbers and bank details are blurred. The amounts are real. I started charging more and more as time went on.
11 checks, $109,124.40, all on totaled cars. These are my shop’s results in just a few weeks.
They threatened to sue. Then they paid in full.
A GEICO total loss, a 2020 Buick Encore. Our invoice was $10,422. The letter we got said only $2,041.20 of it wasn’t in dispute: take that and release the car, or face a lawsuit, a $100-a-day fine and their attorney.
A scary letter is a negotiating move. When your paperwork is signed and your charges are documented, you don’t fold.
The tow truck driver writing us a check for a totaled car.
The insurance company totaled it. We billed for our work, our lot and our storage, and the check got written at a table in our shop before the car was released.
This isn’t a theory. It’s a check, in my shop, on a car the insurance company totaled.
What 10, 20 or 30 total losses are worth
Find the row that looks like your season. Each bar is what you could bill on your total losses at $5,000, $7,000 or $10,000 per car. The black bar at the top is DSM Negotiator for a whole year.
Examples only, not a promise of results. Your numbers depend on your claims, your state and your follow-through.
At the low end, 10 totals at $5,000 is $50,000 against $1,999. The software is the black sliver at the top.
Everything you need to collect.
$1,999 a year, with the full Annual plan of Dent Shop Manager included.
- ✓ Customer total-loss guide What to tell the customer the day the car is totaled, so they stay on your side.
- ✓ Step-by-step negotiation instructions Every pushback the insurance companies use, and the response for each one.
- ✓ Authorization and work order forms The paperwork you need signed before the car is ever written up.
- ✓ DSM Negotiator The AI that drafts the letters and the invoice and keeps the file.
- ✓ The full Dent Shop Manager system Hail maps, canvassing, the claims CRM, paperwork and payroll, unlimited users.
Included: full access to the Dent Shop Manager system
DSM Negotiator comes with the Annual plan of Dent Shop Manager, the shop system it plugs into. Unlimited cars and team members, on the web and on iPhone and Android.
The office on the computer. Techs and reps on their phones. One shop.
Dent Shop Manager runs in any web browser on Windows or Mac, and as a free app for iPhone, iPad and Android. Everyone signs in to the same shop and works from the same cars, files and checklists.
Connect your whole team for one price.
The Monthly plan includes unlimited cars and unlimited team members. You pay per shop, not per seat, so adding another tech or rep never raises your bill. The DSM Negotiator plan includes all of it.
See plansDoing it alone costs more than $1,999.
Most shops fight their first total loss with a phone call and a homemade invoice. The insurance company handles these every day. You handle a few a season, without the training, the customer guide or the scripts. The money you leave on the table while you figure it out is more than a year of the software.
One lowball you accept, or one car that leaves before you are paid, costs more than a year of DSM Negotiator.
Not legal advice. DSM Negotiator is software, not a law firm. Results are not typical or guaranteed.
Want the whole story first? In the free training you will learn:
- → Why the insurance company owes you for the work you did before they totaled the car
- → How mechanic’s liens and the cost of adjusting a loss actually work, in plain English
- → The exact excuses adjusters use, and what to send back
- → How to bill admin, gate and storage on every total loss without losing the customer
Rather talk it through one on one? Book a time on my calendar
Straight answers.
Is this legal?
Yes. Everything we bill is backed by the law and by attorney-reviewed citations. The software cites claim-handling rules only where they exist for your state, and you review every letter before it goes out. It is not legal advice and not a law firm.
Do I need to be good at negotiating?
No. The software reads what the adjuster sent and drafts the reply. Your job is to read it and press send.
What does it cost?
DSM Negotiator is $1,999 a year, and it includes the full Annual plan of Dent Shop Manager. The training is free.
Does it work in my state?
You can bill for your work in any state. Where we’ve verified the law, letters carry attorney-reviewed citations. Everywhere else they argue from your facts and paperwork and cite no statutes. Lien and storage rules vary by state, so check yours.
What if the customer tries to pick up the car?
The car stays until the total loss bill is paid. The customer signed that in your contract, and that’s what a mechanic’s lien is for. Stay calm, explain the bill goes to the insurance company, and get the adjuster on the phone together.
Why do you give me a step-by-step guide?
Because getting paid starts on day one, not when the car gets totaled. The guide shows you what to get signed, what to document and what to say, so every total loss is one you can bill.
What if the adjuster pushes back?
Paste the reply in. The software reads the new tactic and drafts the next, firmer letter.
Results described are from the founder’s own shop and are not typical or guaranteed. Dent Shop Manager is software, not a law firm, and nothing on this page is legal advice.